ECONOMIC ANALYSIS OF PUBLIC EXPENDITUREGROWTH AND OPTIMAL SIZE OF PUBLIC SECTORIN NIGERIA
Get complete chapters, abstract, references and questionnaire delivered to your WhatsApp or email.
Abstract
Public expenditure is used not only to stimulate aggregate demand but
also as a useful tool for redistributing wealth and providing public goods. The
size and object of government expenditure have therefore become a leading
policy issue at most national and international gatherings. To offer the
professional guidance needed on such occasions at the local level, this study
carried out an economic analysis of public expenditure growth and the optimal
size of the public sector in Nigeria, with the federal government as the case
study. The Ordinary Least Squares (OLS) technique was adopted, using Eviews 8
software for data analysis. Annual time series data for 1961–2014 were drawn
from the Central Bank of Nigeria Statistical Bulletin (2009 and 2014), together
with the 2014 World Development Indicators of the World Bank. After the
necessary pre- and post-estimation diagnostic tests, the results show that
average annual government expenditure growth was 1.91 per cent. Tax revenue
from the oil sector was the most influential determinant of public expenditure,
contributing 32.66 per cent of its growth, while tax revenue from the non-oil
sector and the population growth rate were also influential, accounting for
24.29 per cent and 22.49 per cent respectively. The study also found that one
of the core objectives of the Fiscal Responsibility Act of 2007, namely to curb
widely criticized government wastefulness, has not been achieved, since the
dummy for the Act could not influence the growth rate of public expenditure in Nigeria.
Finally, evidence of a non-linear relationship between government expenditure
and economic growth, as predicted by the Armey curve, was found in Nigeria, and
the optimal size of the public sector was estimated at approximately 26.5 per
cent. The study concluded that the above annual growth rate of government
expenditure is not harmful to economic growth, that Nigeria remains an
oil-dependent state in terms of government spending, and that government
expenditure still operates along the growth part of the non-linear curve. Its
recommendations include a possible increase in government spending on sectors
with a high multiplier effect, further diversification of the revenue base away
from oil, and the promotion of transparency and accountability in government
business. In this study, public expenditure (spending) and government
expenditure (spending) are used interchangeably to mean the same thing.
CHAPTER ONE
INTRODUCTION
1.1 Background to the Study
Economic analysis of public expenditure growth is concerned with how the
growth of public expenditure over time influences the overall welfare of the
economy. It involves a critical examination of trends over time and across the
components of public sector spending within the economy. Such analysis is
necessary for an effective evaluation of government performance in carrying out
its obligations in modern economies. The argument rests on the premise that
public expenditure reflects the policy choices of government, which directly or
indirectly shape the fortunes of the whole economy. Public expenditure refers
to the expenses that government incurs for its own maintenance, for society and
for the economy as a whole. It covers items such as defence, general administration,
health, education, electricity generation and supply, roads, telecommunications
and water supply, among others.
Before 1936, the classical economic thinking that characterized most
nation states was built heavily on laissez-faire ideology. This ideology kept
government interference in the economic affairs of individuals and the state to
a minimum, and it restricted the growth of government expenditure to what was
needed to maintain law and order and to defend against external aggression.
Public expenditure, however, grew at an unprecedented rate after the Keynesian
macroeconomic revolution of the late 1930s. In the United Kingdom, for example,
government expenditure as a percentage of gross domestic product (GDP) hovered
between about 9 and 15 per cent between 1890 and 1914. It reached about 48 per
cent during the First World War (1914–1918) and fell to an average of about 27
per cent until 1937, when it began to rise sharply. After the outbreak of the
Second World War (1939–1945), government expenditure rose to about 60 per cent
of GDP in the United Kingdom, but it fell to an average of about 44.9 per cent
from 1948 to 1987. The trend was similar across the major economies, including
the United States.
The rapid growth of public expenditure, and the need to regulate it, led
to several theoretical postulations. They include the Peacock and Wiseman
displacement theory, in which political instability induces government
expenditure, the stages-of-development theory of public expenditure, economic
growth inducing government expenditure, which is known as Wagner's law,
government decentralization inducing government expenditure, which is known as
the Leviathan theory, and the revenue-spend theory, which suggests that the
level of spending in an economy should adjust equivalently to the volume of
revenue generated. All of these are rooted in the traditional economic thinking
of the classical, Keynesian and Wagnerian schools. Recent Nigerian evidence on
these theories is mixed. Obi and Ehiedu (2020) find Wagner's hypothesis to be
valid in Nigeria, with economic growth causing total government expenditure to
rise in the short term, whereas Awode and Akpa (2018), controlling for
structural breaks over 1981–2016, find no support for Wagner's law and show
that oil export earnings positively and significantly influence government
spending. Jibir and Aluthge (2019), using a modified version of Wagner's law
with data for 1970–2017, find that oil revenue, GDP, population, trade
openness, oil price, taxation and inflation are important determinants of the
size of government expenditure in Nigeria.
Economists have also observed the potential consequences of an
unregulated rise in government expenditure for economic growth. A number of
well-established theoretical studies support the claim that a rapid increase in
democratic institutions and a rising demand for the welfare state are
positively correlated with a high rate of growth in the relative size of public
sector spending. Several authors have argued along similar lines that the
long-run relationship between the size of the government sector and economic
growth is concave. This implies that when the government sector is very small,
long-term economic growth can be accelerated by increasing the provision of
public goods. The marginal contribution to growth is positive but decreasing as
the government sector grows larger, and it becomes negative when the additional
costs of expanding the government sector outweigh the benefits of the increased
productivity. The turning point at which an increase in government expenditure
produces the maximum increase in economic growth is known as the optimal size,
or level, of the public sector, and it is the point at which an increase in
government spending, as a proportion of GDP, results in the largest increase in
economic growth. The exact position of this turning point remains unknown and
contentious among researchers. Coayla (2021), reviewing the empirical evidence
on the Armey curve, finds the inverted-U relationship between public spending
and growth in many studies but shows that the threshold differs among them and
that actual spending in different countries lies above or below it. Whatever
the optimal size of an economy's public sector is, it depends largely on
structural factors such as the economic cycle, the structure of public
expenditure and fiscal pressure. Even so, knowing the optimal size of the
public sector is of great importance in the face of the growing need for
effective macroeconomic stabilization policy. Its greatest benefit is that it
gives government insight into how to strike a balance between the supply of
public goods and the achievement of sustainable economic growth.
As a case study, Nigeria is a middle-income country and a mixed economy.
It is an emerging market with expanding financial, services, communications,
technology and entertainment sectors. In 2014 Nigeria's GDP was about $568.51
billion, which represented about 0.92 per cent of the world economy and ranked
it 26th in the world and first in Africa. Its population was estimated at about
177.8 million in 2014, which ranked it seventh in the world. The country has
nevertheless seen an unusually high growth in government expenditure over the
last two and a half decades. Between 1960 and 2013, for example, government
expenditure grew from $291.48 million to $57.49 billion. This growth has yet to
translate into the welfare of citizens, since more Nigerians are poor today
than ever before. The National Bureau of Statistics (NBS, 2022) found that 63
per cent of Nigerians were multidimensionally poor. Analysts blame this
unwanted outcome on the frequent changes in revenue allocation and expenditure
policy, which are widely accused of favouring the federal government at the
expense of the federating units. The justification for the high growth of
federal government spending is therefore a source of unending socio-political
and economic debate in Nigeria.
Professional analysis of public expenditure growth and of the optimal
size of the public sector is now more relevant at a time when development
challenges such as poor infrastructure, high unemployment and insecurity of
life and property are very common. These challenges persist despite the huge
government expenditure budgeted every year to solve them. Studies show that
urbanization, the degree of trade openness, government revenue, inflation,
external reserves, population density, the type of government regime, policy
instability and public debt are key drivers of public expenditure growth in
Nigeria. Following this, the Nigerian government has adopted various fiscal
policy measures to manage public expenditure. Some were aimed at reducing total
expenditure and diversifying revenue mobilization, and others at promoting
transparency and accountability in the management of national resources. The
search for an effective fiscal framework led to the enactment of the Fiscal
Responsibility Act of 2007, which was meant to minimize wasteful government
spending, encourage transparency, consolidate accountability and promote
overall fiscal discipline.
The problem of rising government spending nevertheless remains despite
these control measures. In 1967–1970, 1973–1975 and 1980–1981, for example,
public expenditure growth rates varied from 1.12 per cent to 58.96 per cent,
from 4.48 per cent to 116.84 per cent, and from 102.09 per cent to -23.75 per
cent respectively, while economic growth rates fluctuated between -4.25 per
cent and -1.25 per cent, between 5.8 per cent and 6.2 per cent, and between
-3.2 per cent and -2.9 per cent (Central Bank of Nigeria, 2009; 2012). More
recently, the growth of government expenditure fell from 21.48 per cent in 2010
to -2.27 per cent in 2012 and then rose to 14.23 per cent in 2013, while the
economy grew at 7.84 per cent, 6.75 per cent and 7.31 per cent over the same period.
If it is true that no government is too little, but an all-encompassing
government is too much, the question becomes what the right size of government
is, from the standpoint of maximizing economic welfare in Nigeria. Has the
growth of the public sector in Nigeria been too little, too much or about right
from the standpoint of increasing the output of goods and services? Should
Nigeria expand government financial activities faster or more slowly than the
growth rate of the economy in order to expand the output of goods and services?
These questions have yet to receive the response they deserve from
researchers. Some studies have estimated the determinants of the growth of
government expenditure in Nigeria (Jibir & Aluthge, 2019; Obi & Ehiedu,
2020), and several recent studies have examined the optimal size of the public
sector, with widely different results. Umoru and Onimawo (2020) put the optimal
size at 40 per cent of GDP, Raheem and Ogunleye (2025) at 22 to 24 per cent,
and Aliagan (2025) at about 14 per cent. Many other studies have been more
interested in the impact of government expenditure on economic growth. These
studies rarely estimate the rate at which public expenditure itself grows in
Nigeria. This knowledge gap makes it difficult to establish a dependable link
between the actual and expected rates of government expenditure growth in the
economy. Little or no attention has also been paid to ways of checking the
growth of public expenditure, so the marginal efficiency of the rising
components of government spending cannot be predicted. In addition, detailed
studies of the optimal size of the public sector in Nigeria remain scarce.
1.2 Statement of the Problem
Government expenditure in Nigeria has risen continuously because of
growing oil revenue, increased demand for public utilities and the effect of
inflation on the economy. Shuaibu and El-Yaqub (2024) describe the dependence
of Nigeria's public finances on volatile oil revenue. The increasing need for
security in the face of rising civil unrest, from militancy to terrorism, has
also raised government expenditure. According to the Central Bank of Nigeria
(2012) and the Budget Office of the Federation (2014), government expenditure
on defence was N444.6 billion, N233 billion, N264 billion, N348 billion,
N921.91 billion, N1,055 billion and N968.127 billion from 2008 to 2014
respectively. Public sector analysts also believe that the steady rise in
government expenditure in Nigeria has been driven by the persistent rise in the
cost of general administration, the emoluments of public office holders, the
misallocation of resources, government inefficiency, the personal interests of
politicians and bureaucrats, and debt service and repayment. Central Bank of
Nigeria data (2009; 2012) show that total government expenditure rose
significantly over the last five decades. Total recurrent expenditure rose from
N716.10 million in 1970 to N4,085.20 million, N36,219.60 million, N416,600
million, N3,109,378.51 million and N3,365,760.00 million in 1980, 1990, 2000,
2010 and 2013 respectively. Total capital expenditure was N187.80 million,
N10,163.30 million, N24,048.60 million, N239,450.90 million, N883,874.50
million and N1,621,480.00 million in the same years. The upward trend in
federal government annual expenditure from 1961 to 2013 is clear from these
data.
Despite the continuous rise in annual government spending, Nigeria still
faces a rising incidence of poverty and ranks among the poorest countries in
the world. At the time of the study more than half of Nigerians lived on less
than US$2 a day, and more recent national estimates still put the
multidimensional poverty headcount at 63 per cent (NBS, 2022). Inadequate
infrastructure, especially roads and power supply, impedes industrialization
and sustains a high level of unemployment, and macroeconomic indicators such as
the balance of payments, the inflation rate, the exchange rate and national
savings show that Nigeria has not fared well in the last few years (Central
Bank of Nigeria, 2009).
To finance rising expenditure in this situation, government may raise
taxes or borrow. Higher income tax tends to discourage individuals from working
long hours or even from seeking jobs, which reduces income and aggregate
demand. Similarly, higher profit tax may raise production costs and reduce
investment and the profitability of firms. When firms face falling
profitability, they usually shut down beyond their break-even point. This may
reduce national output, followed by a rise in unemployment. Rising unemployment
in turn reduces household income and leads to a deterioration in the standard
of living of citizens. Furthermore, if the growth of public spending is
financed by borrowing from banks, the borrowing raises interest rates and so
raises the cost of capital to the private sector. This crowds out private
investment and damages economic growth. Recent Nigerian evidence on domestic
borrowing is mixed, but it points the same way on prudence. Onuoha (2024) finds
that domestic debt and public spending have positive effects on growth, but he
recommends strict control of internal borrowing to avoid crowding out, while
Udo Oji and John (2022) find evidence supporting the crowding-out hypothesis.
Alenoghena, Aghughu and Odior (2023) report that after the repayment of foreign
loans in 2006, borrowing came to be dominated by domestic loans. In spite of
this chain of consequences, information from the Debt Management Office, as
cited by the Federal Ministry of Finance (2014), shows that total public debt
rose steadily after the 2005 debt relief. It rose from US$21,398.91 million to
US$25,817.42 million, US$35,097.43 million, US$42,225.6 million and
US$48,496.23 million between 2008 and 2012, and then fell slightly to
US$48,361.37 million in 2013. Annual debt service rose by 20.32 per cent in
2014, from N591.76 billion in 2013 to N712 billion in 2014. This rise
represents an outflow of resources that could have been invested to create
employment for the population.
There is another dimension to the problem. An expanding public sector,
driven by rising government spending, at some point leads to a decline in
economic growth. Some studies find that higher government expenditure on
socio-economic and physical infrastructure encourages economic growth in
Nigeria, while others contend that higher government expenditure, if not
regulated, may slow the overall performance of the economy. As government
expenditure grows without limit, the law of diminishing returns begins to operate,
and beyond some point further increases contribute to economic stagnation and
decline. This happens for two reasons. First, operations are often conducted
inefficiently, which reduces the overall productivity of the economic system.
Second, excessive government spending distorts economic incentives and leads to
sub-optimal economic decisions. Politicians and bureaucrats in Nigeria and
other developing economies also sometimes seek to remain in power by increasing
government expenditure on unproductive projects, or on goods that the private
sector could produce more efficiently.
The debate on the relationship between government size and economic
growth has now shifted from which sign, positive or negative, applies to what
the optimal size of the public sector is. The question now is at what
percentage point an increase in government expenditure would guarantee maximum
economic growth in Nigeria. Since it is always desirable for government
expenditure to stimulate growth and enhance economic welfare, this study
considers it imperative to investigate the growth rate and the growth drivers
of government expenditure in Nigeria. There is also a growing need to
investigate the credibility, or effectiveness, of the Fiscal Responsibility Act
of 2007, and the evidence so far is mixed. Fagge (2018) attributes the limited
shift from a discretionary to a rule-based fiscal system after Nigeria's exit
from the Paris Club to non-strict adherence to the rules in the Act, while Oke
(2026) finds that enforcement of the Act and compliance with the debt rules
were moderate, at 62.4 per cent and 58.9 per cent respectively, but that both
significantly reduced budget deficits when enforced. At the heart of these
needs is the need to estimate the optimal size of the government sector.
Meeting it will give a new lease of life to effective policy making in the
country, help to establish the link between the current economic situation and
the expected fiscal disposition of government, and help the economy to
establish a strong fiscal regime that maximizes economic welfare through
effective government spending.
1.3 Research Questions
In view of the problems stated above, the following research questions
will guide the study:
1. What is the average growth rate of public
expenditure in Nigeria?
2. What are the determinants of public
expenditure growth in Nigeria?
3. How has the Fiscal Responsibility Act
affected the rate of public expenditure growth in Nigeria?
4. What is the optimal size of the public sector
in Nigeria?
1.4 Research Objectives
The broad objective of this study is to analyse public expenditure growth
and the optimal size of the public sector in Nigeria. This will be achieved
through the following specific objectives:
1. Ascertain the average growth rate of public
expenditure in Nigeria.
2. Investigate the determinants of public
expenditure growth in Nigeria.
3. Examine the effect of the Fiscal
Responsibility Act on the growth rate of public expenditure in Nigeria.
4. Estimate the optimal size of the public
sector in Nigeria.
1.5 Research Hypotheses
The research questions above give rise to the following null hypotheses:
Ho1: The average growth rate of public expenditure in Nigeria is not
significant.
Ho2: The effect of the determinants of public expenditure growth in
Nigeria is not significant.
Ho3: There is no significant effect of the Fiscal Responsibility Act on
the rate of public expenditure growth in Nigeria.
Ho4: The optimal size of the public sector in Nigeria is less than 15%.
1.6 Scope of the Study
The scope of this study is limited to an economic analysis of public
expenditure growth and an estimate of the optimal size of the government sector
in Nigeria. The study covers the period 1961 to 2014, using data on federal
government public spending. The researcher intends to obtain information on the
growth of public spending across the different regimes in the country. Many
factors contribute to the growth of government spending, as the empirical
studies show, but this study uses the population growth rate, tax revenue (from
the oil and non-oil sectors), the inflation rate, official external reserves
and the public debt growth rate as proxy determinants of the growth rate of
total government expenditure. Public expenditure as a percentage of GDP is used
together with real gross domestic product (RGDP) to estimate the optimal size
of the public sector. Finally, a dummy variable is generated to investigate the
impact of the Fiscal Responsibility Act of 2007 on the growth rate of
government expenditure in Nigeria.
1.7 Policy Relevance of the Study
The importance of this research lies in the fact that it will serve as a
valuable instrument for policy articulation, and it will be of great relevance
to institutions and individuals. Specifically, it is expected to benefit the
following groups.
The federal government will find the study very useful, since it provides
information on the determinants of growth in public sector spending and on what
the optimal size of the public sector should be in Nigeria. This will help to
curtail unnecessary public sector spending significantly, especially in the
face of declining oil revenue. The study will also be relevant for reversing
the rising public debt and its servicing cost, and so free more resources for
national development.
Non-governmental organizations and international development agencies
will also find the study important, because it will give them reliable
information on key issues in government expenditure in Nigeria. In addition, it
will add to existing knowledge on the scope of government spending in Nigeria.
It will give researchers and students of public sector economics the insight
they need, since it seeks to estimate the optimal size of the public sector in
Nigeria. The study examines the determinants of government expenditure growth
over the past 54 years.
References
Alenoghena, R., Aghughu,
A. A., & Odior, E. S. (2023). Domestic borrowing and the Nigerian economy:
A Bayesian VAR analysis. Journal of Developing Areas, 57(3), 65–77.
Aliagan, M. A. K. (2025).
Government size and economic growth in Nigeria: Can there be too much of a good
thing? Al-Hikmah University Journal.
https://alhikmahuniversity.edu.ng/AJEC/index.php/journal/article/view/52
Awode, S., & Akpa, E.
(2018). Testing Wagner's law in Nigeria in the short and long-run (MPRA
Paper No. 98363). University Library of Munich.
https://econpapers.repec.org/RePEc:pra:mprapa:98363
Coayla, E. (2021). The
optimal size of government and the Armey curve: A review of empirical evidence.
Asian Journal of Applied Economics, 28(1), 121–137.
Fagge, M. A. (2018).
Public debt management in Nigeria: The impacts of institutional changes after
exiting from the Paris Club in 2006. Islamic University Multidisciplinary
Journal, 5(2).
Jibir, A., & Aluthge,
C. (2019). Modelling the determinants of government expenditure in Nigeria. Cogent
Economics & Finance, 7(1), Article 1620154.
https://doi.org/10.1080/23322039.2019.1620154
National Bureau of
Statistics. (2022). Nigeria multidimensional poverty index (MPI) survey
report 2022. https://www.nigerianstat.gov.ng
Obi, C. K., & Ehiedu,
V. C. (2020). Testing the efficacy of Wagner's law on public expenditure in
Nigeria. Scientific Papers of the University of Pardubice, 28(1),
Article 1019.
Oke, O. E. (2026). Fiscal
rules and budget deficit control in emerging economies: Evidence from Nigeria
(2023–2026). International Journal of Research and Innovation in Social
Science, 10(15), 252–266. https://doi.org/10.47772/IJRISS.2026.1015EC00024
Onuoha, N. E. (2024).
Domestic debt, public spending and economic growth in Nigeria: A mediation
analysis. African Journal of Economic and Management Studies, 16(1),
112–126. https://doi.org/10.1108/AJEMS-10-2023-0400
Raheem, A. J., &
Ogunleye, A. G. (2025). Investigating the Armey curve hypothesis in Nigeria: An
empirical analysis. ADSU International Journal of Applied Economics, Finance
and Management.
https://ajaefm.adsu.edu.ng/index.php/journals/article/view/185
Shuaibu, M., &
El-Yaqub, A. B. (2024). A closer look at the nexus between oil price and
non-oil revenue in Nigeria. Iranian Economic Review, 28(2), 369–390.
https://doi.org/10.22059/IER.2022.88412
Udo Oji, G., &
Emmanuel John, C. (2022). Domestic debt effect on Nigeria's economic growth. International
Journal of Business Management, 5(3), 1–15.
Umoru, D., & Onimawo,
J. A. (2020). Determination of optimal size of government in relation to output
growth in Nigeria: A Monte Carlo simulation evidence. Sriwijaya
International Journal of Dynamic Economics and Business, 4(2).
This project contains full academic material including literature review, methodology,
data analysis and conclusion.
VERIFIED COMPLETE RESEARCH PROJECT TOPICS AND MATERIALS
76 PAGES
Need a Custom Project Written for You?
Our professional writers can write a unique, plagiarism-free project on any topic in your department — delivered before your deadline.