THE EFFECTIVENESS OF MONETARY POLICY UNDER FLEXIBLE EXCHANGE RATE REGIME IN NIGERIA.
Get complete chapters, abstract, references and questionnaire delivered to your WhatsApp or email.
CHAPTER ONE
INTRODUCTION
1.1 Background to the Study
The Bretton Woods system of fixed exchange rates emerged immediately
after the Second World War and worked fairly well for nearly thirty years,
until it broke down in 1973. The large US current account deficits caused by
the country’s involvement in the Vietnam War put the system under heavy strain.
After its collapse, a generalised system of floating exchange rates emerged,
particularly among the developed countries. Developing countries have had more
varied experiences with exchange rate regimes. Recent cross-country evidence
indicates that the often-cited shift from fixed to flexible arrangements after
Bretton Woods has been overstated, since regimes with limited flexibility
remain in the majority (Ilzetzki et al., 2019). In choosing a regime, developing
countries need to be fully aware of the circumstances and conditions that make
its adoption successful, and the important factors and criteria behind such
choices must also be properly understood. A wide range of regimes is open to
individual countries. At one extreme is a clean float, or flexible regime, and
at the other is a firmly fixed arrangement, with the remaining regimes falling
along a continuum between them. These include managed floats, pegs, target
zones, currency boards, monetary unions and dollarisation. In the last few
years, a number of developing economies, Nigeria among them, have moved from
fixed to flexible exchange rates. In most cases this has produced instability
in exchange rates and an atmosphere of uncertainty that aggravates inflation.
Recent evidence from Nigeria illustrates the point: exchange rate depreciation
has a stronger and more immediate effect on inflation than appreciation, with a
pass-through that is observed within three to four quarters (Ikue & Emeke,
2024).
Monetary policy and the exchange rate are key tools of economic
management, and of macroeconomic stabilisation and adjustment, in developing
countries such as Nigeria, where non-inflationary growth and international
competitiveness have become major policy targets. The real exchange rate is one
broad measure of international competitiveness, while inflation arises largely
from monetary expansion, currency devaluation and other structural rigidities
in the economy. The question of which exchange rate regime a small open economy
should choose has no definite answer, because the choice depends on the
objectives and priorities of the monetary authorities and on assumptions about
the economy’s structural characteristics. In this sense, structural
characteristics refer to openness, capital mobility, wage indexation and the
level of economic growth and development (Busari et al., 2008). The choice also
matters in practice. A study of about forty emerging market countries over 1986
to 2013 found that the transmission of global financial shocks to domestic
credit, house prices, bank leverage and output is magnified under fixed
exchange rate regimes relative to more flexible, though not necessarily fully
flexible, regimes (Obstfeld et al., 2019).
The formulation and implementation of monetary policy therefore influence
macroeconomic variables, and hence macroeconomic stability, in any economy,
whether developed or underdeveloped. The critical distinction is the degree to
which movements in the exchange rate pass through to domestic macroeconomic
variables, most especially consumer prices, output (measured by Gross Domestic
Product, GDP) and private consumption. The choice of exchange rate regime is
linked, to some extent, to the achievement of specific targets set by the
monetary authorities, which are most often related to internal and external
imbalances. A relationship is therefore expected between the choice of regime
and real output, prices, balance of payments stabilisation and the sources of
shocks hitting the economy (Busari et al., 2008).
When the goal is balance of payments stabilisation, a flexible exchange
rate system is preferable for correcting any current or capital account
disequilibrium. Consideration must then be given to the Marshall-Lerner
conditions, the degree of capital mobility and the foreign reserve constraint.
When the objective is to stabilise domestic prices, the issue of financial
discipline becomes relevant. Many economists believe the exchange rate can
serve as an anchor for financial stability because it is a single price in the
economy, and in this sense a fixed rate imposes discipline by discouraging
recourse to inflationary finance. Proponents of flexibility argue the contrary:
announcing a fixed rate only invites financial crises followed by continuous
devaluation. Finally, when the objective is to stabilise real output, the
exchange rate regime is mainly viewed as a shock absorber, and the choice of
regime is used to spread the effects of shocks. The choice therefore depends on
the nature of the shocks and the structural characteristics of the economy.
There appears to be a clear trade-off between output and consumption volatility
on the one hand and inflation volatility on the other. Where exchange rate
pass-through is very high, all monetary rules face a significant trade-off, and
the same trade-off appears between fixed and flexible exchange rates (Busari et
al., 2008). Whereas the inflation rate is often used to track movements in the
domestic price level, the exchange rate is used as a policy tool for securing external
stability and enhancing export performance (Caballero & Corbo, 1989).
Exchange rate policy also affects the outcome of stabilisation measures and
debt management strategies, especially in developing countries (Busari &
Olayiwola, 1999).
In general, both fiscal and monetary policies seek to achieve relative
macroeconomic stability. The Keynesians argued that fiscal policy is more
potent than monetary policy, while the monetarists, led by Milton Friedman,
held the opposite view. Azam (2001) describes macroeconomic instability as a
situation of economic malaise in which the economy has not settled into a
steady equilibrium, which makes prediction and good planning difficult. Because
the rate of interest is the cost of credit, monetary policy covers the control
of the money supply, through the control of high-powered reserves, and of the
rate of interest (Iyoha, 2002). The success of monetary policy depends on the
operating economic environment, the institutional framework adopted and the choice
and mix of instruments (Nnanna, 2001). This is why the Central Bank of Nigeria
(CBN) considered it necessary to reassess and evaluate its monetary policy
implementation framework continuously, so that it could respond to a changing
economic and financial environment. Embedded in these objectives is a separate
but closely related financial surveillance, or stability, role. To realise the
goal of monetary and macroeconomic stabilisation, the CBN deploys its monetary
policy instruments in such a way as to secure optimal outcomes for inflation,
the exchange rate and growth.
The relevance of the question has continued to grow since the period
covered by this study. In June 2023 Nigeria moved from a multi-window, managed
exchange rate system to a floating regime, and a 2026 IMF staff study has
examined how this change altered interest rate and exchange rate pass-through
and the effectiveness of monetary policy (Melo Fernandes & Stumphius,
2026). Reporting on that study notes that monetary policy transmission, which
broke down under the earlier stabilised arrangement of 2016 to 2023, was
restored after the reforms, while currency movements became a more important
driver of inflation (BusinessDay, 2026). These developments confirm that the
interaction of monetary policy and the exchange rate regime remains central to
macroeconomic management in Nigeria. The present study, however, examines the
period stated in its scope.
1.2 Statement of the Problem
Since the mid-1970s, developing countries have moved either to pegging to
a basket of major currencies, in place of a single-currency peg, or to a more
flexible exchange rate regime. To reduce the uncertainties created by medium-
and long-term swings in the major currencies, which have caused them various
problems, they have tended to adopt intermediate regimes rather than the polar
regimes of firmly fixed or freely floating rates. This pattern is consistent
with the finding that regimes with limited flexibility remain in the majority
worldwide (Ilzetzki et al., 2019).
Under the Structural Adjustment Programme, Nigeria’s economy was
deregulated in 1986 and a market-based framework for determining the exchange
rate was adopted. The policy was meant to serve the goal of export promotion,
together with other export measures such as the export incentives and
miscellaneous provisions decrees of 1986. Despite these measures, external
sector performance has remained poor and unimpressive, and the outcomes of
exchange rate policy remained unstable. Other sectoral policies consequently
failed badly, as the targets for other macroeconomic aggregates, including
interest rate, inflation rate, unemployment and money supply, remained largely
unrealised (Ifionu et al., 2007).
Since the early 1990s, two developments have shaped the type of exchange
rate regime adopted by developing countries: the intensification of
globalisation and the emergence of financial crises. The deep integration of
many developing countries into the global economy has promoted trade in goods
and services between developed and developing or emerging market economies. The
choice of exchange rate regime is therefore of crucial importance for
protecting these countries from speculative attacks and currency crises and for
achieving long-term growth. It also bears on which regime best prevents massive
capital inflows and currency crises while facilitating trade, foreign direct
investment (FDI) and economic growth. The evidence that regimes shape how
global financial shocks are transmitted to domestic credit and output (Obstfeld
et al., 2019) underlines why this choice cannot be treated lightly. For a
developing country, greater access to global capital markets creates a policy
dilemma over the choice of regime, and selecting an appropriate exchange rate
is not a straightforward task. It has been suggested that the appropriate
exchange rate varies with the specific circumstances of the country and of the
period in question (Frankel, 1999).
Yet following the currency and financial crises of the 1990s, many
developing countries were advised to move to the polar regimes, that is, either
flexible rates or fixed rates backed by a monetary union or currency board. The
reasoning is that intermediate regimes are no longer tenable, given the
trilemma embodied in the impossible trinity. The trilemma refers to the
difficulty of pursuing exchange rate stability, capital mobility and
independent monetary policy at the same time. All three cannot be achieved
together; at most two can be, so at least one must be sacrificed. The argument
goes on that, as more countries seek access to global financial markets, the
choice narrows to the degree of flexibility, between perfect free floating and
hard fixes such as monetary union, a currency board or even dollarisation. This
accords with the view of some analysts that certain countries are better suited
to a fixed regime with a monetary union or currency board, while others are
better off with a flexible regime. The conventional portrayal of the trilemma
has itself been amended in recent work, which argues that many countries’
record accumulation of reserves since 2002 reflects a desire to stabilise
exchange rates in an environment of reduced capital controls (Ilzetzki et al.,
2019).
Nevertheless, little can yet be claimed about which exchange rate regimes
actually work. As Velasco (2000) observed, during the 1997 to 1998 Asian
crisis, arrangements that had performed relatively well for years collapsed
with almost no advance notice, and others that had seemed invulnerable nearly
collapsed as well. Mid-course corrections and policy changes proved equally
troublesome: in every country that abandoned a peg and floated, the exchange
rate overshot massively and a period of currency turmoil followed, with heavy
real costs. In choosing exchange rate regimes, therefore, developing countries
need to be fully aware of the circumstances and conditions for their successful
adoption, and the important factors and criteria behind such choices need to be
properly understood.
A number of empirical studies show that changes in the exchange rate are
among the factors behind variations in inflation in Nigeria. Studies of
exchange rate pass-through to consumer prices in the country have, however,
yielded no clear direction (Ugwu et al., 2021), and more recent work finds that
the pass-through is asymmetric between depreciation and appreciation (Ikue
& Emeke, 2024). Ukwu et al. (2003) observed that there is general agreement
that a low long-term rate of inflation can be achieved by limiting the growth
of broad monetary aggregates sufficiently over a long period. As at 2005,
inflation and the exchange rate remained high and volatile. This is not good
for the economy, since it becomes difficult for investors to make sound and
stable business decisions in such conditions, and it represents a major
constraint on the opportunities for stabilisation through monetary policy in
Nigeria. It has also been observed that monetary policy stimulates growth
better under a flexible rate regime, but this is accompanied by severe
depreciation, which could destabilise the economy. Despite these observations,
the effectiveness of monetary policy in macroeconomic stabilisation under the
exchange rate regime has received comparatively little attention in Nigeria,
creating an information gap at the expense of economic expansion. Against this
background, this study seeks to investigate the interaction between monetary
policy, macroeconomic stabilisation and the exchange rate regime in Nigeria.
The research questions that arise from the foregoing are as follows:
a)
What is the effectiveness of monetary policy in
stabilising output growth under a flexible exchange rate regime?
b) Has
monetary policy been effective in reducing inflation under a flexible exchange
rate regime?
c)
How has monetary policy helped to achieve balance of
payments (BOP) stability under a flexible exchange rate?
1.3 Objectives of the Study
The broad objective of this research is to analyse monetary policy and
macroeconomic stabilisation under alternative exchange rate regimes. The study
specifically seeks to:
a)
examine the effectiveness of monetary policy in
stabilising output growth in Nigeria under a flexible exchange rate regime;
b) determine
the effectiveness of monetary policy in reducing inflation using a flexible
exchange rate in Nigeria; and
c)
examine how monetary policy can achieve BOP stability
under a flexible exchange rate in Nigeria.
1.4 Research Hypotheses
Based on the objectives outlined above, the study is guided by the
following hypotheses:
a)
Monetary policy is not effective in achieving economic
growth in Nigeria under a flexible exchange rate regime.
b) Monetary
policy is not effective in reducing inflation using a flexible exchange rate in
Nigeria.
c)
Monetary policy cannot achieve BOP stability under a
flexible exchange rate in the Nigerian economy.
1.5 Policy Relevance
(i) The
study will be valuable to policy makers and government in assessing the
effectiveness of monetary policy and macroeconomic policy in stabilising the
economy under a flexible exchange rate regime.
(ii) Its
results will give deeper insight into the relationship between monetary policy
and the exchange rate in Nigeria.
(iii) It
will add to the existing literature on the subject and serve as a reference for
research in similar studies.
1.6 Scope of the Study
This study is limited to the Nigerian economy for the period 1990 to
2008. The period was chosen to provide an adequate number of observations for
time series analysis.
REFERENCES
BusinessDay. (2026). IMF
says Nigeria’s FX reforms revived monetary policy as floating naira reshapes
inflation.
https://businessday.ng/news/article/imf-says-nigerias-fx-reforms-revived-monetary-policy-as-floating-naira-reshapes-inflation/
Ikue, N. J., & Emeke,
N. J. (2024). Asymmetric exchange rate pass-through and inflation rate in
Nigeria. International Journal of Research in Business and Social Science,
13(7), 282–292.
Ilzetzki, E., Reinhart, C.
M., & Rogoff, K. S. (2019). Exchange arrangements entering the twenty-first
century: Which anchor will hold? The Quarterly Journal of Economics, 134(2),
599–646. https://doi.org/10.1093/qje/qjy033
Melo Fernandes, C., &
Stumphius, C. (2026). Nigeria’s shift to a floating regime: Interest rate
and exchange rate pass-through and policy effectiveness (IMF Selected
Issues Paper SIP/2026/045). International Monetary Fund.
https://www.imf.org/-/media/files/publications/selected-issues-papers/2026/english/sipea2026045.pdf
Obstfeld, M., Ostry, J.
D., & Qureshi, M. S. (2019). A tie that binds: Revisiting the trilemma in
emerging market economies. The Review of Economics and Statistics, 101(2),
279–293. https://doi.org/10.1162/rest_a_00740
Ugwu, E., Amassoma, D.,
& Ehinomen, C. (2021). Investigating exchange rate pass-through to consumer
prices in Nigeria. Folia Oeconomica Stetinensia, 21(1), 105–121.
https://doi.org/10.2478/foli-2021-0008
This project contains full academic material including literature review, methodology,
data analysis and conclusion.
VERIFIED COMPLETE RESEARCH PROJECT TOPICS AND MATERIALS
97 PAGES
Need a Custom Project Written for You?
Our professional writers can write a unique, plagiarism-free project on any topic in your department — delivered before your deadline.